“Another one” First things first! “Yankees Add Former Mets First Baseman Dominic Smith on Minor League Deal, Quietly Addressing Depth Needs While Steering Clear of Alonso Trade Buzz”…
The New York Yankees made an intriguing roster move by signing former New York Mets first baseman Dominic “Dom” Smith to a minor league contract.
This decision, though not as headline-grabbing as other offseason moves, has sparked conversation among fans and analysts.
While many expected the Yankees to make a splashier acquisition, the signing of Smith represents a strategic move aimed at bolstering depth and exploring untapped potential.
Who is Dominic Smith?
Smith, now 29 years old, was a highly touted prospect when the Mets selected him 11th overall in the 2013 MLB Draft.
His early career was marked by high expectations, as his minor league performances showcased his ability to hit for both average and power.
However, transitioning to the majors proved challenging. Smith experienced inconsistent playing time, defensive adjustments, and injuries that hampered his development.
His best season came in the pandemic-shortened 2020 campaign when he slashed .316/.377/.616 with 10 home runs in just 50 games. That performance highlighted his potential as a power-hitting first baseman with the ability to contribute in clutch situations.
However, subsequent seasons were less fruitful, and Smith struggled to replicate that level of success. In 2023, he spent time with both the Cincinnati Reds and the Boston Red Sox, appearing in 93 games and posting a modest .691 OPS.
Why Did the Yankees Sign Smith?
The Yankees’ interest in Smith stems from a combination of need and opportunity. After parting ways with veteran Anthony Rizzo, who has battled injuries and seen a decline in performance, the Yankees sought depth at first base.
While the team also signed Paul Goldschmidt to a one-year, $12.5 million deal, Smith’s addition provides a low-risk, high-reward option for the organization.
Smith’s defensive versatility is another factor that likely appealed to the Yankees. Although primarily a first baseman, he has experience playing in the outfield, which could give the team flexibility in roster construction.
His left-handed bat also adds balance to a Yankees lineup that has historically leaned heavily on right-handed power hitters.
What Does This Mean for the Yankees?
Smith’s signing represents a strategic gamble by the Yankees. While expectations for his immediate impact might be tempered, the team is banking on the possibility that a change of scenery and access to their coaching resources could help him rediscover his 2020 form.
A successful stint in the minors or a strong showing in spring training could position Smith as a valuable contributor, either as a platoon option at first base or as a left-handed bat off the bench.
The move also underscores the Yankees’ approach to roster building this offseason.
Rather than focusing solely on marquee signings, they are making calculated decisions to address specific needs while maintaining financial flexibility.
By signing Smith to a minor league deal, the team minimizes risk while leaving room for other potential acquisitions or midseason adjustments.
The Context of Mets-Yankees Rivalry
The signing of a former Mets player by the Yankees always adds an extra layer of intrigue, especially given the close proximity and history of the two franchises.
However, it’s important to note that this move is far removed from the drama surrounding current Mets star first baseman Pete Alonso. Alonso, who has been the subject of trade rumors and speculation about his future with the Mets, was never seriously linked to the Yankees this offseason.
The acquisition of Smith is unrelated to those rumors and represents a practical, rather than provocative, decision by the Yankees.
Final Thoughts
While Dominic Smith may not be the big-name signing some Yankees fans were hoping for, his addition to the organization is a savvy move with potential upside.
If he can recapture his previous form, he could become a valuable asset for a team looking to reclaim its status as a World Series contender.
For now, Smith’s signing is a low-risk experiment, but it could pay dividends in the long run as the Yankees continue to fine-tune their roster ahead of the 2025 season.
