Signing update: “With or without him” Six Viable Alternatives for the Red Sox to Strengthen Third Base Without Pursuing Alex Bregman or Nolan Arenado…
The Boston Red Sox, in their pursuit of championship contention, are looking to bolster their roster, particularly at third base or with versatile options who can complement their lineup and defensive alignment.
If Alex Bregman and Nolan Arenado are off the table, here are six potential options that could meet their needs while aligning with their long-term and short-term goals.
1. Matt Chapman (Free Agent)
Matt Chapman is an elite defensive third baseman, widely regarded as one of the best gloves in the league at his position. His combination of defensive excellence and power at the plate makes him a strong fit for Fenway Park.
Though his offensive production can be streaky, his ability to drive the ball into gaps and his power swing would likely benefit from Fenway’s dimensions. Chapman is also a respected clubhouse presence, which would align with Boston’s culture-building goals.
- Pros: Three-time Gold Glove winner, above-average power hitter, solid veteran presence.
- Cons: Inconsistent offensive production and potential for a high price tag in free agency.
Chapman would bring stability and a defensive anchor to the Red Sox’s infield, providing immediate improvement to their roster.
2. José Ramírez (Cleveland Guardians)
José Ramírez is a dream target for any team seeking a complete player. He’s a switch-hitter with excellent plate discipline, power, and speed, making him one of the most dynamic players in baseball.
Although the Guardians have resisted trading him in the past, Boston could put together an enticing package featuring top prospects like Marcelo Mayer or Nick Yorke.
Ramírez’s ability to play third base and his consistent offensive production make him a perfect fit for the Red Sox. Adding his bat to the middle of the lineup would transform their offense while maintaining defensive quality.
- Pros: Elite offensive skills, base-stealing threat, proven track record.
- Cons: High trade cost, including top-tier prospects, to acquire him from Cleveland.
If the Red Sox want a star-caliber player who can help them win immediately, Ramírez would be worth the investment.
3. Ke’Bryan Hayes (Pittsburgh Pirates)
Ke’Bryan Hayes is a young, up-and-coming third baseman who excels defensively and has shown flashes of offensive potential. While his power numbers haven’t fully developed, he’s a steady contact hitter with room to grow.
The Pirates might not be eager to trade him, given his team-friendly contract, but the Red Sox could make a compelling offer centered on their surplus of minor-league talent.
At only 27 years old, Hayes would give Boston a long-term solution at third base, combining elite defense with a developing bat. His presence would also allow the team to focus on other areas without worrying about the hot corner for years to come.
- Pros: Exceptional defense, affordable contract, potential for offensive improvement.
- Cons: Still developing offensively; acquiring him could be costly.
Hayes fits into both a rebuilding or contending window, making him a versatile option for the Red Sox.
4. Eugenio Suárez (Seattle Mariners)
Eugenio Suárez provides an affordable power bat at third base. While his strikeout rate is a concern, his ability to hit 30+ home runs consistently would inject serious power into Boston’s lineup.
Suárez is also a durable player who has played a full slate of games in recent seasons. His defensive ability is above average, which would complement Boston’s needs.
The Mariners may consider moving Suárez in a deal to reallocate resources, and the Red Sox could acquire him without sacrificing top-tier prospects.
His right-handed power bat would fit well in Fenway Park, particularly with the Green Monster looming in left field.
- Pros: Consistent power hitter, durable, relatively affordable trade target.
- Cons: High strikeout rate, limited offensive versatility beyond home runs.
Suárez represents a cost-effective way to address both power and defensive concerns at third base.
5. Yonny Hernández (San Francisco Giants)
For a less conventional option, the Red Sox could consider trading for Yonny Hernández.
While Hernández doesn’t possess the power or star potential of other options, he’s a versatile infielder with elite contact skills and above-average speed. His versatility allows him to play third base, shortstop, or second base, providing depth and flexibility for the roster.
Hernández wouldn’t be a splashy acquisition, but he could fit into the Red Sox’s desire to create a dynamic lineup that prioritizes on-base percentage and small-ball strategies.
Adding Hernández would also give them flexibility in deploying players like Trevor Story or Rafael Devers.
- Pros: Versatility, contact skills, speed.
- Cons: Limited power, more of a utility player than an everyday star.
Hernández might not solve all the Red Sox’s problems, but he could be a valuable piece in a more comprehensive roster overhaul.
6. J.D. Davis (San Francisco Giants)
J.D. Davis is a solid all-around third baseman who combines decent offensive production with passable defense.
While not a superstar, Davis has shown he can be a productive player in the right environment. His ability to hit for both average and power, paired with his versatility to play multiple positions, makes him an attractive mid-tier option.
If the Giants make Davis available, the Red Sox could add him without emptying their farm system. He could serve as a bridge player while Boston develops younger talent or waits for a better long-term opportunity.
- Pros: Affordable trade option, consistent hitter with moderate power.
- Cons: Average defensive skills, not a long-term solution.
Davis would bring stability and depth to Boston’s roster, filling a key need without breaking the bank.
Strategic Considerations
When deciding on a path forward, the Red Sox must balance immediate competitiveness with their long-term goals. Players like Chapman, Ramírez, and Hayes offer strong options for teams with different timelines.
While Chapman and Ramírez provide immediate star power, Hayes represents a younger, longer-term solution. Meanwhile, more affordable options like Suárez, Hernández, or Davis offer flexibility for a team looking to avoid overcommitting financially or depleting their farm system.
The decision will ultimately hinge on Boston’s confidence in their ability to contend in 2025 and beyond. If they view themselves as close to playoff contention, a bold move for a star like Ramírez might make sense.
However, if they see themselves as a team in transition, targeting affordable, versatile players such as Hayes or Davis could set them up for sustained success in the years to come.
In any case, the Red Sox have numerous paths forward that don’t involve Alex Bregman or Nolan Arenado, ensuring they can still make impactful moves to reshape their roster.
